Quellcode durchsuchen

List specific non-goals in design principles page

Thomas Kluyver vor 6 Jahren
Ursprung
Commit
88f56f9e86
1 geänderte Dateien mit 28 neuen und 0 gelöschten Zeilen
  1. 28 0
      doc/design.rst

+ 28 - 0
doc/design.rst

@@ -49,3 +49,31 @@ ways it can still help you:
   create command-line entry points, to find ``makensis.exe`` on Windows, and so
   create command-line entry points, to find ``makensis.exe`` on Windows, and so
   on. You can take specific bits to reuse, or copy the whole thing and apply
   on. You can take specific bits to reuse, or copy the whole thing and apply
   some changes.
   some changes.
+
+Specific non-goals
+------------------
+
+These are ideas that I've considered and decided not to do:
+
+- Concealing source code: I'm writing Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) and
+  I want to help other people do the same. A core FOSS principle is that the
+  user can inspect and understand the code they are running. I'm not interested
+  in anything that makes that harder.
+- Detecting dependencies by finding ``import`` statements: My experience is that
+  this doesn't work well. It misses dynamically loaded dependencies, and it
+  can have false positives where a module is only needed in some situations.
+  I think specifying all modules needed is clearer than specifying
+  corrections to what a tool detects.
+  I am interested in dynamically finding dependencies by running a program;
+  see my prototype `kartoffel <https://pypi.org/project/kartoffel/>`_ tool if
+  you want to investigate this.
+- Single-file executables: You could probably reuse a lot of Pynsist's code to
+  make single-file executables. They would 'install' to a temporary directory
+  and then run the application. But it's not a feature I'm planning to include.
+- MSI packages: They have some advantages, but they're much more complicated to
+  make than NSIS installers. I have `an experiment with using WiX
+  <https://github.com/takluyver/pynsist/tree/wixperiment/examples/_mu>`_ in a
+  branch; feel free to use it as a starting point.
+
+These aren't set in stone: I've changed my mind before, and it could well
+happen again.